Settlement Agreements and Discrimination Claims

Understanding how discrimination claims affect settlement values and why legal advice is crucial.

Quick Answer

Discrimination claims under the Equality Act 2010 can be brought immediately—there is no qualifying service requirement. Settlement values are typically higher than unfair dismissal claims because discrimination awards include compensation for injury to feelings, which can reach £100,000 or more in serious cases.

What is Discrimination at Work?

Discrimination at work means being treated unfairly because of a protected characteristic. The Equality Act 2010 is the primary UK law protecting employees from discrimination. Unlike unfair dismissal claims, which require two years' qualifying service, discrimination claims can be brought immediately—even on your first day of employment.

Discrimination is prohibited at every stage of employment, from recruitment through to dismissal. It can occur in direct form (you are treated worse because of your protected characteristic) or indirect form (a policy or practice appears neutral but places people with your characteristic at a disadvantage).

The key difference between discrimination and other unfair treatment is that discrimination must be based on a protected characteristic. Being treated unfairly for other reasons might be unfair dismissal, but not discrimination. However, if you are treated unfairly because of a protected characteristic, you have a discrimination claim—regardless of how long you have been employed.

Protected Characteristics Under the Equality Act 2010

The Equality Act 2010 protects nine characteristics. Discrimination based on any of these is illegal:

Age

Being treated less favourably because you are older or younger than colleagues.

Disability

Discrimination against employees with physical or mental disabilities, including failure to make reasonable adjustments.

Gender Reassignment

Discrimination based on someone's gender identity or status as a transgender person.

Marriage or Civil Partnership

Less favourable treatment based on marital or civil partnership status.

Pregnancy and Maternity

Discrimination during pregnancy, maternity leave, or related health conditions.

Race

Discrimination based on race, colour, nationality, or ethnic or national origins.

Religion or Belief

Discrimination based on religious beliefs or lack thereof (including atheism).

Sex

Discrimination based on being male or female, including sexual harassment.

Sexual Orientation

Discrimination based on being lesbian, gay, bisexual, or heterosexual.

If you have experienced unfavourable treatment because of any of these characteristics, you may have a discrimination claim. Settlement agreements relating to discrimination claims are often highly valuable because discrimination is treated as a serious violation of employment law, and awards can be substantial.

How Discrimination Affects Settlement Values

Discrimination claims often settle for higher values than other employment disputes because they include additional heads of damage:

Components of Discrimination Compensation

  • Loss of wages: Compensation for lost income from the date of dismissal until you find alternative employment, or the date of settlement.
  • Loss of benefits: Compensation for pension contributions, bonuses, healthcare, or other contractual benefits lost due to dismissal.
  • Injury to feelings: Compensation for the emotional distress caused by discrimination. This is typically the largest component and can range from £1,000 to £100,000+ depending on severity, length of period, and impact on health and wellbeing.
  • Personal injury damages: If discrimination caused physical or mental health conditions (stress, depression, anxiety), compensation for medical treatment and ongoing effects.
  • Future loss: Compensation for difficulty in finding alternative employment, career disruption, or ongoing disadvantage.
  • Interest: Interest on compensation from the date of the discriminatory act to the date of settlement.

The "injury to feelings" component is what makes discrimination claims particularly valuable. Tribunals recognise that discrimination is not just unfair treatment—it is a violation of fundamental human rights. Awards for injury to feelings have increased substantially over recent years and now reflect the serious nature of discrimination.

No Qualifying Service Requirement

A critical advantage of discrimination claims is that there is no qualifying service requirement. You can bring a discrimination claim on day one of employment, or even in the recruitment process if you have been discriminated against.

This means that if you are dismissed and suspect discrimination, the lack of two years' service does not prevent you from bringing a claim. Many employers are aware of this and are particularly motivated to settle discrimination claims quickly to avoid tribunal proceedings and potential publicity.

If you have been in employment for less than two years, a discrimination claim may be your only avenue of redress if you are dismissed unfairly. This is why understanding whether discrimination might be involved in your dismissal is so important.

Common Discrimination Scenarios

Discrimination can take many forms. Here are typical scenarios where settlement agreements are offered:

Age Discrimination

An older employee is dismissed after a restructure whilst younger colleagues performing similar roles are retained. Comments about "bringing in fresh blood" or "needing energy" may indicate age discrimination.

Pregnancy Discrimination

A woman is dismissed whilst on maternity leave, or shortly after returning, or is not offered the same opportunities as before her pregnancy. Pregnancy discrimination is particularly serious and attracts high awards.

Disability Discrimination

An employee with a disability is dismissed without reasonable adjustments being made, or is treated less favourably because of disability-related absences or performance issues arising from their disability.

Race Discrimination

An employee from a minority ethnic background is overlooked for promotion, subjected to offensive comments, or dismissed on pretextual grounds whilst colleagues of other races are treated more favourably.

Sexual Orientation or Gender Identity Discrimination

An employee is dismissed or treated unfavourably following disclosure of sexual orientation or gender identity, or subjected to harassment or exclusion by colleagues or managers.

In each case, settlement agreements offered by employers reflect their desire to avoid tribunal publicity and potentially substantial awards. This is your opportunity to ensure fair compensation.

Why Legal Advice is Essential for Discrimination Claims

Discrimination claims are complex, and settlement offers can vary enormously depending on the strength of your case. An employment law adviser can help you understand:

  • Whether the treatment you received amounts to discrimination under the Equality Act 2010
  • How strong your claim would be at tribunal
  • What a tribunal would likely award in compensation
  • Whether the settlement offer is fair, or whether you should negotiate for more
  • Risks of proceeding to tribunal versus accepting settlement
  • How to maximize tax-efficient compensation

Legal requirement: Under section 203 of the Employment Rights Act 1996, you must receive independent legal advice before signing a settlement agreement. This is not optional—it is a legal requirement to make the agreement binding and enforceable.

Because discrimination awards can be substantial—often £20,000-£100,000+ in serious cases—investing in legal advice can result in significant additional compensation. An adviser who negotiates on your behalf might increase the settlement by £10,000, £20,000, or more. This easily outweighs the cost of legal advice.

Factors Affecting Discrimination Compensation

Unlike unfair dismissal, which has statutory maximum awards, discrimination compensation is unlimited. Tribunals assess damages based on actual loss and the severity of the discrimination. Key factors include:

Severity of Discrimination

Isolated remarks: lower awards. Systematic harassment: higher awards. Public humiliation: even higher.

Duration

Single incident: lower. Ongoing over months or years: substantial awards reflecting cumulative impact.

Impact on Health

Documented mental health issues, stress, depression: significantly increases injury to feelings award.

Salary and Position

Higher earners typically receive higher compensation, though this is not always proportional.

Employer's Conduct

Whether employer covered up discrimination or failed to investigate complaints—aggravating factors increase awards.

Financial Loss

Unmitigated loss (you haven't found work) increases compensation. Minimal loss (you found equal work quickly) reduces it.

Discrimination awards are highly fact-specific, which is why professional advice is so valuable. An experienced adviser can provide a realistic assessment of your claim's value and negotiate effectively with the employer.

Tax Treatment of Discrimination Settlements

The tax treatment of discrimination compensation is complex. Generally:

  • Compensation for injury to feelings is tax-free
  • Loss of earnings may be taxable (unless it falls within the £30,000 exemption for loss of office)
  • Medical expenses or treatment are usually tax-free
  • Interest on compensation may be taxable

Your adviser will help structure the settlement agreement to optimise tax treatment. Working with a solicitor who understands both employment law and tax can ensure you keep more of your compensation.

Key Takeaways

  • Discrimination claims can be brought immediately—no qualifying service requirement.
  • Nine protected characteristics are covered: age, disability, gender reassignment, marriage/civil partnership, pregnancy, race, religion/belief, sex, sexual orientation.
  • Discrimination awards include injury to feelings, which can be very substantial (£1,000-£100,000+).
  • Settlement values for discrimination are often higher than unfair dismissal because awards are unlimited.
  • Legal advice is mandatory under s.203 ERA 1996 before you can sign a binding settlement agreement.
  • An experienced adviser can significantly increase your settlement through expert negotiation.
SM

Written by Steven Mather, Solicitor

Steven is a business law solicitor who has been advising on settlement agreements since 2008. He practises through Nexa Law (SRA regulated) and is a member of the Law Society Council. He believes everyone deserves clear, honest advice when facing a difficult time at work.

Connect on LinkedIn →

Believe you've experienced discrimination at work? Let's protect your rights.

Expert legal advice on discrimination claims and settlement agreements. Your protected characteristics are protected by law.

No obligation. Initial response usually same day.